Miami Beach vs San Francisco: One City is a $105K Trap

Hi {{first_name|nurse,}}

Two nurses. Same RN license. One makes $105,890 more per year. But she only keeps $1,300 more per month.

That's the Miami Beach vs San Francisco nursing story in one sentence. And it's exactly why salary numbers lie.

These are two of America's most searched nursing cities. San Francisco promises six-figure salaries and California's famous nurse-to-patient ratios. Miami Beach offers sunshine, no state income tax, and that Florida lifestyle everyone on Instagram seems to have.

But when you actually run the numbers? It's complicated.

San Francisco nurses make $105,890 more per year. But they also pay $39,892 more in taxes annually. That's the California state income tax doing its thing. Florida has zero state income tax, which sounds amazing until you realize it doesn't matter if your salary is $100K lower.

Then there's housing. A $1.3 million average home price in San Francisco sounds insane. Because it is. Your monthly mortgage would be $6,972. In Miami Beach, you're looking at $2,772 for a place that costs $517,399. Neither is cheap. But one is absolutely crushing.

Here's what shocked me: even after paying that massive San Francisco mortgage, you still have $3,244 left over each month. In Miami Beach? Only $1,944. The salary difference is big enough to overcome the housing difference and the tax difference.

The math gets even more interesting when you factor in what else costs more. Gas, groceries, insurance, going out—everything costs more in San Francisco. But everything also costs more in Miami Beach than people think. It's not some cheap Southern city anymore. It's a luxury coastal market.

Miami Beach nursing jobs center around Mount Sinai Medical Center, Jackson Health System, and Baptist Health. These aren't small operations. Mount Sinai is a major teaching hospital with good ICU experience opportunities. But the pay is what it is—Florida hospital systems don't compete with California wages.

The job market is tight but growing. Florida's population is exploding with retirees and remote workers moving in. That means more patients, more clinics, more need for nurses. Travel nursing is active here, paying around $2,200-2,800/week. That's decent but not West Coast money.

The lifestyle is the sell. No state income tax. Warm weather year-round. Beach access. But the insurance costs after hurricanes are brutal. Your car insurance is expensive. Your homeowners insurance is worse. And the humidity will make you question every life choice between June and October. Miami Beach also has serious traffic and parking costs that eat into your budget in ways you don't expect.

San Francisco is a different game entirely. UCSF Medical Center is one of the top hospitals in America. Kaiser Permanente has a massive presence. Sutter Health, CPMC, SF General—you've got options. And they pay. Union protections through the California Nurses Association mean enforceable staffing ratios and real bargaining power.

Those staffing ratios matter. California law mandates 1:2 in ICU, 1:5 in med-surg, 1:5 in psych. You're not drowning in patients the way you might be in other states. The working conditions are genuinely better, and that's worth something when you're thinking about burnout. Travel contracts here can hit $3,000-4,000/week when there's demand.

But let's be real about the downsides:
• The cost of living is absurd
• A 500-square-foot apartment can cost $3,000/month
• Parking costs money everywhere
• A burrito costs $15
• Your taxes are high on everything—income, sales, gas
• The homeless crisis is visible and can be heavy to witness daily
• Unless you're making that $178K, you might be living with roommates or commuting from Oakland or Daly City
• Many SF nurses live outside the city and commute in because even with high salaries, buying in SF proper is nearly impossible

San Francisco wins on take-home money, even after the brutal taxes and insane housing costs. If you can handle the cost of living and lifestyle, you'll keep about $1,300 more per month. That's $15,600 per year to save, invest, or pay down loans.

Miami Beach isn't a trap, but it's not the tax-haven paradise people think. Lower salary plus expensive coastal housing equals less money in your pocket every month.

Don't move to either city based on vibes or weather. Run your actual numbers first. Factor in your specialty, your rent vs buy plans, and what you'd really spend.

Compare any two cities and see what you'd actually keep at MapMyPay.com. The salary number is just the starting point. What you keep is what matters.

VIP subscribers get:
✓ Detailed city insights (hospitals, job market, lifestyle)
✓ Weekly interview tips for relocating nurses
✓ Hospital system deep-dives

Upgrade to VIP →

If you haven’t downloaded it yet, you can do it right now. No more waiting. No more guessing your real take-home pay.

Here’s what you’ll get inside:

✅ See after-tax nursing salaries across 1,000+ U.S. cities
✅ Compare leftover income after rent or mortgage
✅ View crime stats, housing costs, and cost-of-living in any city
✅ Filter by shift, role, or how much money you want left over
✅ Join a private, nurse-only community where receipts (and pay stubs) speak louder than opinions

We built this for you—because you deserve to know where your money goes and where it goes further.

👇 Haven’t downloaded it yet? Grab it now:

Talk soon,
Jason from Map My Pay

P.S. We’re posting daily in Map My Pay’s community section. Make sure to join us there and ask your most important questions.